Describe the discrepancy before reaching a conclusion

When labels, quantities, or documents differ from an order, record the agreed requirement alongside the observed condition. An order may require a single lot while received labels show two lots; a label may carry a suffix that differs from the agreed ordering code. These observations require investigation. They are not automatically confirmed counterfeits, and visual similarity is not a reason to overlook them.

Create one shared reference

Use an order-line reference or discrepancy identifier to connect the purchase order, quotation revision, delivery note, receipt date, and quantity received. Number photographs and reports so that repeated forwarding does not disconnect them from the goods. If one package has several discrepancies, use linked references to keep quantity reconciliation separate from quality findings.

  1. Preserve the requirement: record the complete MPN, manufacturer, quantity, lot and packing restrictions, and any written exceptions agreed by both parties.
  2. Record the delivery: capture observable information on outer cartons, inner packaging, labels, and affected devices. Separate quantities by lot or package identifier.
  3. Connect evidence: photograph the relationship between packaging and labels, retain original files, and associate complete reports and attachments with the same record.
  4. State current status: note whether material has been opened, sampled, or used, and who holds it. Mark unknown information as unknown.

Keep the material and records reviewable

Follow the buyer’s quality procedures to identify disputed material separately and hold it from use pending a disposition decision by the designated reviewer. Retain packaging and delivery documents. Before cleaning, relabeling, repacking, or destructive analysis, consider whether the action would change evidence needed for review. Where further action is required, the responsible person should record the reason and the condition before and after. Do not alter an original marking to produce a clearer photograph.

Give the supplier answerable questions

A useful discrepancy notice includes the order line, agreed condition, actual observation, affected quantity, evidence references, and requested clarification. Use a mutually accepted channel for confidential material and provide only information needed for review. Requests may concern label identity, matching documents, or quantity reconciliation. Further testing, replacement, or return requires consideration of the order and agreement between the parties.

For example, if a packing-list quantity differs from receipt, distinguish carton count, units per package, and the counting method. If a document is later found to belong to another carton, preserve the original record and add the correction with its evidence. This is a hypothetical workflow example.

Retain the decision and its basis

Track investigation status separately from material disposition. If the cause remains unknown, record it as unknown and name the investigation owner. An agreed return or replacement can still be recorded with its basis; do not invent a root cause to close the disposition task. Record affected lots, quantities, and approval grounds for acceptance, continued hold, or other action, and retain unresolved technical questions as open items. This guide establishes no universal claim deadline, refund condition, or quality warranty; actual order terms and applicable requirements govern those matters.

For a KETAIC order, this evidence checklist can support a joint review. A record connecting the order, packages, and documents helps define the issue and avoids applying one lot’s findings to unrelated material.

Editorial note

This article provides procurement recordkeeping guidance. Confirm inspection requirements and order-handling conditions during quotation and order acceptance.